Notice: We are currently performing maintenance to improve the italaw platform. The site remains fully accessible. Thank you for your patience.

Fireman's Fund Insurance Company v. The United Mexican States, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/02/1

New
Short Name:

Fireman's Fund v. Mexico

Case Type:
International Investment Agreement (Investor–State)
Applicable Procedural Rules:
ICSID
Seat of Arbitration:
Toronto (Canada)
Applicable Treaty:
North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) (1994), North American Free Trade Agreement (1992)
Applicable Legal Instruments:
NAFTA
Economic Sector:
, Financial and Insurance Activities
Outcome:
In Favour of Respondent(s)
See case mapped on Investor-State LawGuide

Available documents

19 Nov 1999
Notice of Intent (Spanish)
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
Notice of Intent (Spanish)
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Respondent appointee
Tribunal/Panel chair
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Respondent's counsel
Other counsel
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
Respondent's witness
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
Notice of Intent (Spanish)
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.


29 Nov 2000
Amended Notice of Intent (Spanish)
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
Amended Notice of Intent (Spanish)
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Respondent appointee
Tribunal/Panel chair
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Respondent's counsel
Other counsel
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
Respondent's witness
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
Amended Notice of Intent (Spanish)
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.


30 Oct 2001
Notice of Arbitration
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
Notice of Arbitration
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Respondent appointee
Tribunal/Panel chair
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Lawrence W. Newman
Respondent's counsel
Other counsel
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
Respondent's witness
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
Notice of Arbitration
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.


21 Oct 2002
Mexico's Submission on Preliminary Issues of Jurisdiction (Spanish)
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
Mexico's Submission on Preliminary Issues of Jurisdiction (Spanish)
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Respondent appointee
Tribunal/Panel chair
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Respondent's counsel
Other counsel
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
Respondent's witness
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
Mexico's Submission on Preliminary Issues of Jurisdiction (Spanish)
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.


20 Dec 2002
Claimant's Memorial on the Preliminary Question
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
Claimant's Memorial on the Preliminary Question
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Respondent appointee
Tribunal/Panel chair
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Daniel M. Price
Respondent's counsel
Other counsel
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
Respondent's witness
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
Claimant's Memorial on the Preliminary Question
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.


24 Feb 2003
Mexico's Response to the Tribunal's Questions on Preliminary Issues (Spanish)
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
Mexico's Response to the Tribunal's Questions on Preliminary Issues (Spanish)
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Respondent appointee
Tribunal/Panel chair
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Respondent's counsel
Other counsel
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
Respondent's witness
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
Mexico's Response to the Tribunal's Questions on Preliminary Issues (Spanish)
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.


24 Feb 2003
Claimant's Response to the Tribunal's Question of February 13, 2003
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
Claimant's Response to the Tribunal's Question of February 13, 2003
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Respondent appointee
Tribunal/Panel chair
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Daniel M. Price
Respondent's counsel
Other counsel
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
Respondent's witness
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
Claimant's Response to the Tribunal's Question of February 13, 2003
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.


27 Feb 2003
First Submission of Canada Pursuant to Article 1128 of the NAFTA
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
First Submission of Canada Pursuant to Article 1128 of the NAFTA
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Respondent appointee
Tribunal/Panel chair
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Respondent's counsel
Other counsel
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
Respondent's witness
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
First Submission of Canada Pursuant to Article 1128 of the NAFTA
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.


27 Feb 2003
Submission of the United States of America
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
Submission of the United States of America
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Respondent appointee
Tribunal/Panel chair
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Respondent's counsel
Other counsel
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
Respondent's witness
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
Submission of the United States of America
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.


17 Jul 2003
Decision on the Preliminary Question (English)
Decision on the Preliminary Question (Spanish)
Document provided by: ICSID
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
Decision on the Preliminary Question (English)
Decision on the Preliminary Question (Spanish)
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Claimant appointee:
Andreas Lowenfeld
Respondent appointee
Respondent appointee:
Francisco Carrillo Gamboa
Tribunal/Panel chair
Chair/President:
Albert Jan van den Berg
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Respondent's counsel
Other counsel
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
Fernando Borja Mujica, Eduardo Fernández García
Respondent's witness
Luis Mancera de Arrigunaga
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
Decision on the Preliminary Question (English)
Decision on the Preliminary Question (Spanish)
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.


17 Jul 2006
Award (redacted version) (English)
Award (redacted version) (Spanish)
Document provided by: ICSID
Document Details:
PARTICIPANTS
Award (redacted version) (English)
Award (redacted version) (Spanish)
Participants listed are for this document only and may not include all participants involved in the entire case. Always consult the original documents.
Claimant appointee
Claimant appointee:
Andreas Lowenfeld
Respondent appointee
Respondent appointee:
Alberto Guillermo Saavedra Olavarrieta
,
Respondent appointee:
Francisco Carrillo Gamboa
Tribunal/Panel chair
Chair/President:
Albert Jan van den Berg
Arbitrator(s)
Sole Arbitrator
ICSID Annulment Committee president
ICSID Annulment Committee members
WTO Appellate Body members
WTO Appellate Body chair
Judges
Claimant's counsel
Stanimir A. Alexandrov, Lawrence W. Newman, Raymundo E. Enriquez, Daniel M. Price
Respondent's counsel
Hugo Perezcano Díaz
Other counsel
Rodney Neufeld, Keith Benes, Renee Gardner, Gary Sampliner, Yannick Mondy, Jason Kearns, Kimberly Evans
Claimant's expert
Respondent's expert
Claimant's witness
William M. Isaac, Rubén Acosta Carrasco, Gerhart E. Reuss, José Antonio García
Respondent's witness
Fernando Luis Corvera Caraza, Patrícia Armendáriz Guerra, José Angel Gurría, Sergio Méndez Santa Cruz, Alfonso Orozco, Guillermo Zamarripa Escamilla, Carlos Sempé Minvielle, José Vicente Corta Fernández
Other witnesses
Tribunal secretary
Claudia Frutos-Peterson
Tribunal assistant
Country
Print reporter
Entities
Document Summary
Award (redacted version) (English)
Award (redacted version) (Spanish)
This summary note is machine-generated. Always consult the original materials.