Gabriel Resources Ltd. and Gabriel Resources (Jersey) v. Romania, Procedural Order No. 10 - Annex B

This HTML version is machine-generated. Always consult the original document.

[Page 1]

PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 10 – ANNEX B

TRIBUNAL’S DECISIONS ON RESPONDENT’S REQUESTS TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS DATED 08 JUNE 2018

RESPONDENT’S REPLY TO CLAIMANTS’ OBJECTIONS TO RESPONDENT’S REQUESTS TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS

***

[Page 2]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
1.	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 3]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 4]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 5]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 6]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 7]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).

[Page 8]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 9]

5.	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Claimants’ agreement to produce all responsive documents in their possession, custody or control is noted.
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 10]

[Redacted]

Granted, subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2). To the extent that any responsive documents are subject to legal privilege, Claimants shall follow the procedure set out in PO 10 (see PO 10, paras 47 and 55.3).

[Page 11]

[Redacted]

[Page 12]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 13]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2). To the extent that any responsive documents are subject to confidentiality, Claimants shall follow the procedure set out in PO 10 (see PO 10, paras 53 and 55.4).

[Page 14]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 15]

[Redacted]

Granted, subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2). To the extent that any responsive documents are subject to confidentiality, Claimants shall follow the procedure set out in PO 10 (see PO 10, paras 53 and 55.4).

[Page 16]

10.

[Redacted]

Granted, subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2). To the extent that any responsive documents are subject to confidentiality, Claimants shall follow the procedure set out in PO 10 (see PO 10, paras 53 and 55.4).

[Page 17]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 18]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Respondent limiting the request in terms of time. To the extent that any responsive documents are subject to legal privilege, Claimants shall follow the procedure set out in PO 10 (see PO 10, paras 47 and 55.3).

[Page 19]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 20]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Respondent limiting the request in terms of time. To the extent that any responsive documents are subject to legal privilege, Claimants shall follow the procedure set out in PO 10 (see PO 10, paras 47 and 55.3).

[Page 21]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 22]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 23]

[Redacted]

[Page 24]

14.	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted as narrowed down by Respondent and subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 25]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Respondent limiting the request in terms of time and subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2). Claimants shall produce a colour copy of the Community Development Plan dated 2003.

[Page 26]

[Redacted]

[Page 27]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 28]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted only with respect to the environmental and social impact of the Project.
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 29]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 30]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted to the extent that the request covers documents in the custody, possession or control of Claimants and does not require a more general search of documents and/or information in the public domain.

[Page 31]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 32]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Claimants’ agreement to produce the document should they locate it is noted.
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted subject to Respondent limiting the request in terms of time and subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).

[Page 33]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 34]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Respondent limiting its request in terms of time and subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).

[Page 35]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted subject to Respondent limiting its request in terms of time and subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).

[Page 36]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 37]

22.	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted but limited to the specified local association and subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 38]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 39]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 40]

[Redacted]

Granted, subject to Claimants’ confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2). To the extent that any responsive documents are subject to confidentiality, Claimants shall follow the procedure set out in PO 10 (see PO 10, paras 53 and 55.4).

[Page 41]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Claimants' agreement to produce the requested document is noted.
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 42]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants' confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 43]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 44]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Claimants' agreement to produce all responsive documents in their possession, custody or control is noted.
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 45]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 46]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
27.	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted.

[Page 47]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted only with respect to executed agreements.

[Page 48]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted.

[Page 49]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted only with respect to items (a) to (d) and subject to Claimants' confirmation that they have

[Page 50]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).

[Page 51]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 52]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants' confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).

[Page 53]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants' confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their

[Page 54]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).

[Page 55]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 56]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants' confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).

[Page 57]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted.

[Page 58]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 59]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted.

[Page 60]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 61]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
5	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Claimants' agreement to produce all responsive documents in their possession, custody or control is noted. Respondent's understanding that Claimants have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody or control is also noted.

[Page 62]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Claimants' statement that the requested documents do not exist is noted. Respondent's remark is also noted.
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted. To the extent that any responsive documents are subject to legal privilege, Claimants shall follow

[Page 63]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	the procedure set out in PO 10 (see PO 10, paras 47 and 55.3).

[Page 64]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted only with respect to the Allianz flashings in the press report referred to in the press.

[Page 65]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted, subject to Claimants' confirmation that they have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody and control (see PO 10, paras 40 and 55.2).

[Page 66]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 67]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted with respect to the appendices specified by Respondent.

[Page 68]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 69]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Claimants' statement that the requested documents do not exist is noted. Respondent's remark is also noted.

[Page 70]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted.

[Page 71]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 72]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Rejected. The request is overly broad.

[Page 73]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Rejected. The request is overly broad.

[Page 74]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Claimants' agreement to produce all responsive documents in their possession, custody or control is noted. Respondent's understanding that Claimants have produced all responsive documents in their possession, custody or control is noted.

[Page 75]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Rejected. The request is overly broad.

[Page 76]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Respondent's agreement to withdraw its request is noted.

[Page 77]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]

[Page 78]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	See Claimants' letter of 28 May 2018. Claimants are directing RMGC to provide copies to the Parties of the documents requested in accordance with the Protocol Agreement concluded between the Parties. Respondent's letter of 4 June 2018 is also noted.

[Page 79]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	See Claimants' letter of 28 May 2018. Claimants are directing RMGC to provide copies to the Parties of the documents requested in accordance with the Protocol Agreement concluded between the Parties. Respondent's letter of 4 June

[Page 80]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	2018 is also noted.
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	See Claimants' letter of 28 May 2018. Claimants are directing RMGC to provide copies to the Parties of the documents requested in accordance with the Protocol Agreement concluded between the

[Page 81]

No.	Respondent's requests	Justification for requests and relevant references	Claimants' position	Respondent's Response¹	Tribunal's decision
					Parties. Respondent's letter of 4 June 2018 is also noted.

[Page 82]

[Redacted]

See
Claimants'
letter of 28
May 2018.
Claimants
are directing
RMGC to
provide
copies to the
Parties of the
documents
requested in
accordance
with the
Protocol
Agreement
concluded
between the
Parties.
Respondent's
letter of 4
June 2018 is
also noted.

[Page 83]

[Redacted]

Claimants'
statement
that the
requested
documents
are not in
their
possession,
custody, or
control is
noted.
Respondent's
remark is
also noted.

[Page 84]

[Redacted]

Claimants'
statement
that the
requested
documents
are not in
their

[Page 85]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	possession, custody, or control is noted. Respondent's remark is also noted (see response in Request no. 53 above).
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Granted. To the extent that any responsive documents are subject to legal privilege, Claimants shall follow the procedure set out in PO 10 (see PO 10, paras 47 and 55.3).

[Page 86]

[Redacted]

[Page 87]

[Redacted]

Granted. To
the extent
that any
responsive
documents
are subject to
legal
privilege,
Claimants
shall follow
the procedure
set out in PO
10 (see PO
10, paras 47
and 55.3).

[Page 88]

[Redacted]

[Page 89]

[Redacted]

[Page 90]

57.

[Redacted]

Rejected.

[Page 91]

[Redacted]

[Page 92]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Rejected.
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Claimants' agreement to produce the requested documents should they discover that

[Page 93]

[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	the documents in exist and that they are within their possession, custody or control is noted.
[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	[Redacted]	Claimants' agreement to produce the requested documents should they discover that the documents in exist and that they are within their possession, custody or control is noted.

[Page 94]

[Redacted]